ALL FEATURES  |  ALL FULL ISSUES  |  ISSUE 31

I Counted the Referendum Ballots. The Chaos Was No Accident.

I Counted the Referendum Ballots. The Chaos Was No Accident.

Originally published on November 15, 2026 in issue 31 of Forward Weekly


“So much chaos, just so much chaos,” I overheard an Elections Alberta officer mutter to herself as she shuffled past my workstation.

“Chaos” isn’t a word you ever want to associate with your electoral system, yet that’s what it had become on the evening of Oct. 19. Ironic given that hand counting every ballot, a measure that was touted to instill faith in the process, was what was causing the chaos in the first place. 

But then, Bill 20, the Local Authorities Election Act, was never really about that. When the ban on electronic tabulators in provincial elections passed in May 2024, it was plain political maneuvering pandering to the conspiracy-minded fringe making a play for control of the UCP. Who could have predicted that two years later, Elections Alberta would have to hand count 22.1 million ballots by hand? Well, Premier Danielle Smith, for one, when she tried even harder to please her base with 10 referendum questions.

To pull off a ballot counting the size of a federal election, Elections Alberta had to contract 48,000 people from across the country. From my perspective as a political spectator, this seemed obviously fraught, but I wanted  to see it for myself. 

As a contract Counting Officer, I witnessed one of the most poorly coordinated, disorganized undertakings I have ever participated in. But what I experienced was not the result of a single poorly planned chapter in Alberta history, but a pattern of UCP decision-making that has facilitated the gradual decompensation of the fundamental instrument of free and fair elections. 


None of this should have been surprising. Hand counting is well documented as slower, costlier and more prone to human error than electronic tabulation.

My training as a Counting Officer was quick and cavalier; a harried trainer skimmed through terms and protocols I suspect many in the room weren't familiar with. With three weeks before election night, I hoped I’d remember enough to do my job well. 

Arriving at a south Edmonton sports centre on Oct. 19, I joined 250 ballot counters as we waited on the clock for more than two hours before counting began. Although we had been told our signed oaths were mandatory, no one asked to see them. Instructions were delivered without a microphone in the cavernous complex; when my team asked to hear them again, help was promised but never came. Untrained supervisors gave contradictory answers to questions like: “Is this ballot refused or rejected?” One even temporarily misplaced a box of counted ballots. From the floor, the process appeared to lack planning, resources and oversight.

None of this should have been surprising. Hand counting is well documented as slower, costlier and more prone to human error than electronic tabulation. A February 2026 Alberta Municipalities report had already documented the staffing difficulties, worker fatigue and arduous ballot reconciliation it created during the 2025 municipal elections. With 10 referendum questions to count, we could easily  have expected 10-times the  dysfunction.

It would be easy to point a finger at Elections Alberta — except that would be shooting the beleaguered messenger. Over the past 24 months, the organization solely responsible for safeguarding our democratic rights has been asked to do more with less. Tasked with administering independent, non-partisan elections, enforcing financial rules and overseeing recalls and citizen initiatives, how can Elections Alberta be effective if it is pushed beyond its capacity?

Since 2021, the United Conservative Party has steadily altered Elections Alberta’s role, resources and independence. During the Kenney era, Bill 51, the Citizen Initiative Act, and Bill 52, the Recall Act, which enabled petition-led recalls, were passed, creating new and significant duties for Elections Alberta. The UCP also eliminated the independent Office of the Election Commissioner, which investigated violations of election-finance law — including the “kamikaze” campaign scheme that helped propel Kenney to power — claiming it would save taxpayers a whopping $200,000, roughly the cost of a single set of city traffic lights.

Danielle Smith’s contributions to Elections Alberta’s dysfunction went further. Her government enacted Bill 54, the Election Statutes Amendment Act, bringing sweeping changes to Alberta elections that Chief Electoral Officer Gordon McClure himself warned would impair his office’s ability to work. The bill, he told the legislative assembly, “will deteriorate the service provided to electors, compromise Albertans' trust in the democratic process, and remove elements of transparency and accountability”  — that is, erode the principles of democracy itself.

Last December, Bill 14, the UCP passed the Justice Statutes Amendment Act, which shifted authority over citizen initiatives from the chief electoral officer to the Alberta Justice Minister, prompting McClure to warn that “the potential harm of perceived partisan influence over electoral processes cannot be overstated.”

That was the legislative lead-up to the confusing, chaotic Oct. 19 referendum — but  the UCP’s attempts to erode  Alberta’s democracy haven’t stopped. Last spring, the government rejected the independent Electoral Boundaries Commission’s proposed map and ordered an expedited redraw aimed at restoring two rural ridings — a move widely accused of gerrymandering. The replacement map was all but certain to pass when the legislature resumed after the referendum. With less than a year before the next provincial election, Elections Alberta had little time to rebuild its systems around 91 significantly altered constituencies. In an Oct. 30 letter, McClure said Elections Alberta — already strained by petitions, recalls, the referendum and budget cuts — could not adequately implement new electoral boundaries in time for the scheduled Oct. 18, 2027 election and asked the government to retain the existing boundaries or change the election date. Justice Minister Mickey Amery responded in a letter posted on X that they would go ahead with the changes on the same date as planned.

It’s impossible not to see the toll UCP’s legislative history has taken on Elections Alberta. I saw the impact on the ground during the embarrassing execution of the referendum count, which was clearly beyond the organization's capacity and was conducted by overtaxed, under-resourced staff. McClure has repeatedly written to the government outlining the threats to Elections Alberta’s effectiveness, its ability to uphold the public trust and its arm’s-length operations due to the burdens the UCP has placed on it. He has repeatedly begged to maintain the guardrails of the democratic process and has been publicly rebuked for it.

As we speed towards the next provincial ballot counting, one far more consequential than the Oct. 19 boondoggle, I’m keeping a thought for Gordon McClure, and taking his warnings to heart: we must be vigilant and use every process we have to ensure Alberta’s voice is represented accurately and fairly in the results.

About the Author

Heather Inglis is a multi-award-winning theatre director, producer, writer and dramaturg whose career spans the country. 


A note from Forward Weekly on opinion content: The opinions expressed in this feature article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Forward Weekly or its publisher, editors, staff, or affiliates.

ALBERTA POLITICS. DELIVERED.

Subscribe to Forward Weekly for Free

Sign up below to receive Forward Weekly in your inbox each Sunday. You will also receive occasional important updates on key issues from Forward Canada.

By submitting this form, you agree to receive Forward Weekly and other occasional messages from Forward Canada by email or text (if you provide your mobile number). You can unsubscribe at any time using the instructions in each message.

Validating...
Validating...
Validating...
Validating...
Validating...
Data never shared or sold